Remix.run Logo
refulgentis 18 hours ago

Not that I know of.

I just took any indication that the parent post meant absolute zero moderation as them being a bit loose with their words and excitable with how they understand things, there were some signs:

1. it's unlikely they completed an API integration quickly enough to have an opinion on military / defense image generation moderation yesterday, so they're almost certainly speaking about ChatGPT. (this is additionally confirmed by image generation requiring tier 5 anyway, which they would have been aware of if they had integrated)

2. The military / defense use cases for image generation are not provided (and the steelman'd version in other comments is nonsensical, i.e. we can quickly validate you can still generate kanban boards or wireframes of ships)

3. The poster passively disclaims being in military / defense themself (grep "in that space")

4. it is hard to envision cases of #2 that do not require universal moderation for OpenAI's sake, i.e. lets say their thought process is along the lines of: defense/military ~= what I think of as CIA ~= black ops ~= image manipulation on social media, thus, the time I said "please edit this photo of the ayatollah to have him eating pig and say I hate allah" means its overmoderated for defense use cases

5. It's unlikely openai wants to be anywhere near PR resulting from #4. Assuming there is a super secret defense tier that allows this, it's at the very least, unlikely that the poster's defense contractor friends were blabbing about about the exclusive completely unmoderated access they had, to the poster, within hours of release. They're pretty serious about that secrecy stuff!

6. It is unlikely the lack of ability to generate images using GPT Image 1 would drive the military to Chinese models (there aren't Chinese LLMs that do this! even if they were, there's plenty of good ol' American diffusion models!)

Wowfunhappy 16 hours ago | parent | next [-]

I'm Tier 4 and I'm able to use this API and set moderation to "low". Tier 4 only requires a 30 day waiting period and $1,000 spent on credits. While I as an individual was a bit horrified to learn I've actually spent that much on OpenAI credits over the life of my account, it's practically nothing for most organizations. Even Tier 5 only requires $5,000.

OP was clearly implying there is some greater ability only granted to extra special organizations like the military.

With all possible respect to OP, I find this all very hard to believe without additional evidence. If nothing else, I don't really see a military application of this API (specifically, not AI in general). I'm sure it would help them create slide decks and such, but you don't need extra special zero moderation for that.

throwup238 15 hours ago | parent | next [-]

> With all possible respect to OP, I find this all very hard to believe without additional evidence. If nothing else, I don't really see a military application of this API (specifically, not AI in general). I'm sure it would help them create slide decks and such, but you don't need extra special zero moderation for that.

I can't provide additional evidence (it's defense, duh), but the #1 use I've seen is generating images for computer vision training mostly to feed GOFAI algorithms that have already been validated for target acquisition. Image gen algorithms have a pretty good idea of what a T72 tank and different camouflage looks like, and they're much better at generating unique photos combining the two. It's actually a great use of the technology because hallucinations help improve the training data (i.e. the final targetting should be invariant to a T72 tank with a machine gun on the wrong side or with too many turrets, etc.)

That said, due to compartmentalization, I don't know the extent to which image gen is used in defense, just my little sliver of it.

cuuupid 10 hours ago | parent [-]

We can talk about it here, they put out SBIRs for satellite imagery labeling and test set evaluation that provide a good amount of detail into how they're using it.

spauldo 10 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

There are plenty of fairly mundane applications for this sort of thing in the military. Every base has a photography and graphic design team that makes posters, signs, PR materials, pamphlets, illustrations for manuals, you name it. Imagine a poster in the break room of a soldier in desert gear drinking from his/her canteen with a tagline of "Stay Alive - Hydrate!" and you're on the right track.

Wowfunhappy 6 hours ago | parent [-]

You don't need a special no moderation version to do that stuff.

bayesianbot 13 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

Tier 4 requires $250 spent. I'm tier 4 as well and I can see how they get easily mixed, but it actually says $1,000 spent to move to next tier.

Wowfunhappy 13 hours ago | parent [-]

Oops, thank you! So, even easier!

cuuupid 10 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

I am actually talking about the OpenAI API :)

I'm not aware of the moderation parameter here but these contractors have special API keys that unlock unmoderated access for them, they've apparently had it for weeks.