Remix.run Logo
xp84 2 days ago

Most cities and towns were built hundreds of years before most cities and towns in America were, so they're dense (because people needed to walk everywhere), which is perfect for rail.

Take a look at a satellite view of the suburban areas where most Americans actually live. They're mostly post-1950 and were built with basically the opposite assumptions as Europe:

1. Homes spaced generously with residential districts stretching out tens of miles in every direction from the dense-ish core.

2. Homes fully isolated from business districts (i.e. anywhere anyone would want to go)

3. High-speed arterial stroads or, in tonier suburbs, basically expressways, which serve as the connection between neighborhoods.

4. Offices and other workplaces dispersed into strip malls, long stroads, and industrial parks throughout an area, rather than concentrated in a primary central business district.

Turning all that into a cool Dutch city or town where people are going to bike or take trains everywhere pretty much requires bulldozing and starting again. Again I say this with no judgment, I think 'Not Just Bikes,' for instance, makes a perfectly good case that our way is lame and the Dutch are doing great. But realistically I would never hold my breath expecting the US to transform even 1/10 of the way to the Europe style of transport.