Remix clone Hacker News

Total strawman argument.

The size of the country has almost no bearing on the way we develop our towns and cities, subsidize car production, assume/require car ownership in public policy, etc.

It's also quite the stretch to claim the UK as the best country in the EU and even more to claim that it doesn't also have a car culture. And it's not just "America's worst state", the vast majority of US town and cities are car dependent.

▲

ryandrake 3 days ago | parent | next [-]

Any time someone uses the excuse that “the size of the USA” prevents this or that, then ask why New Jersey can’t do this or that. Some states are the same size and density of the average European country.

▲

nebula8804 3 days ago | parent | next [-]

NJ has an extensive train network. Its crap for the following reasons(only referring to main interstate rail, their city light rails are different):

1. The stock is divided into two sets: single decker trains that are falling apart but are still better than new stock because they were designed during an era where there was actual consideration given to comfort. They are old and run down but more comfy.

The new double decker trains are a design by committee nightmare: they have uncomfortable molded chairs made mostly out of plastic, super cold, noisier due to the terrible shifting whine of the electric motors, and now poorly maintained (god help you if you have to use their rest rooms).

2. They are constantly stopping due to priority given to amtrak and commercial rail. In the best case scenario the train takes ~45 mins to get from central NJ to NYC with stops. For about ~20 miles of track distance, that averages out to ~29-31mph. If Amtrack stops you that time is extended.

3. Very slow speeds due to old track technology.

4. Rising ticket costs for the same lousy service. (~$21 round trip from central NJ to NYC) I guess being able to have a digital ticket helps? (It probably helps them more than it helps you)

5. Pure depression because outside the main routes going into NYC and Hoboken, the dregs of society are the only ones riding these trains. This really grates on you if you take the train for years like I did.

6. Recently, they couldn't even provide working windows so people can see the 'beauty' of NJ. ( To be fair after all the TikTok meme videos called them out on this they finally got embarrassed enough to start replacing them: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=j-a3r6i4hiQ )

It all priorities. People in the US just dont want mass rail over other priorities. The people who do are internet keyboard warriors.

▲

tmnvdb 3 days ago | parent | prev [-]

It's obviously nonsense. Nobody is walking from Paris to Berlin. But you can walk in Paris and Berlin.

▲

mlinhares 3 days ago | parent | next [-]

Don't forget one of the most famous and visited destinations in the country is a walkable neighborhood served by great public transportation and uses a rat as a mascot.

▲

nebula8804 3 days ago | parent [-]

You looked at that transportation recently? It is collapsing due to legacy, graft, and cost overruns. I don't presume you are European but I HATE when they use this system as an example or public transit that works in America. Its a dump. The worst trains in France and Germany run miles around it.

	▲	mlinhares 5 hours ago \| parent [-]
		I'm talking about Disney World, not NYC :P

▲

pyfon 3 days ago | parent | prev | next [-]

They can catch a train from Paris to Berlin (and every disco they'll be in)

	▲	tmnvdb 2 days ago \| parent [-]
		Most people would not. Paris - Berlin is dominated by flying.

▲

PaulDavisThe1st 3 days ago | parent | prev [-]

Well, Werner Herzog, possibly.

▲

pinkmuffinere 3 days ago | parent | prev [-]

Your criticisms are absolutely right. I upvoted you, but just fyi I think your response may come off as too blunt/rude, and get “downvotes”. It doesn’t really matter here, but maybe helpful to know in general, if you didn’t already.

	▲	nlarew 5 hours ago \| parent [-]
		Fair enough! You're right it's a bit blunt. I didn't take very much time to edit it. Hopefully folks are able to look past any gruffness and find the substance in it.