Remix.run Logo
ben7799 4 days ago

As others have said this is interesting but use of Ultimate Guitar is flawed as the tabs/scores are so bad on that site, very often not even being close to the real chords.

On top of being simplified tons and tons of songs get rewritten with a Capo so people can just play G-C-D shapes, if your analysis doesn't look for "Capo" and then transpose all the chords then you end up overrepresenting the key of G and it's chords. Then very often 7th chords, Sus chords, etc.. all get transcribed down to major chords & minor chords due to the beginner focus. Interestingly he doesn't include 6th chords as their own thing.

To be fair there are tons of songs that do actually use those chords, so they may still end up coming out as the most popular.

I have a grandfathered in lifetime membership to UG that I only had to pay once for. It was cheap so worth it, but I really find the site kind of icky as they are mostly monetizing crowd sourced low quality work and it's very often wrong. And they nerfed their iPad app recently which is really annoying.

strunz 4 days ago | parent | next [-]

The fact that the data showed only 6% of Metal songs having power chords should've told him to throw the data out the window. UG has terrible tabs/charts.

YZF 4 days ago | parent | prev | next [-]

It's really not that bad. It's a mix. There are also many versions for most songs and often comments with corrections.

Learning songs by ear is probably a useful skill that people don't develop because of all the other sources of information... but probably helps more people play which is good.

dyauspitr 4 days ago | parent | prev | next [-]

They have quite a few versions usually but the most accurate version is usually the one with far and away the most positive reviews/upvotes.

kjkjadksj 4 days ago | parent | prev [-]

The power tabs and guitar pro tabs are a big step up over the text based stuff on ug. You can play it in midi and see they are usually perfect.

ben7799 4 days ago | parent | next [-]

Obviously I've had access to those for a long time. I would still say they are nowhere near as good as published material. And sometimes I've seen the community text ones actually be more correct.

Really a question of how much you pay for it. Sounds like some plans are $25/month, that's enough to just buy tons of published material instead. I paid $5 for a lifetime membership.. very worth it.

pc86 4 days ago | parent | prev [-]

It sounds perfect which is part of it, but if you've ever looked at the Pro tabs, especially the vocal transcriptions, the fretboard positions are all over the place, seem to be wrong about half the time, and in the worst cases I've seen nearly physically impossible to play.

Also for unknown reasons (licensing?) it's impossible to have the vocal track play when you're using a backing track.