Remix.run Logo
constantcrying 5 days ago

No. There is no duty to publish anything.

Intellectual property is about someone having ownership over an idea. It does not mean that you have a right someone gives his idea to you. These are totally separate things.

I am free to write, paint, code or film whatever I want. I have zero obligation to share that with anyone.

Retric 5 days ago | parent [-]

More accurately: Intellectual property is about someone having ownership over information, as a photo for example isn’t an idea.

Remove it and you can’t retaliate against anyone buying or selling access to your company’s source code thus making it impossible to keep private. So all such source code ends up public at any reasonably large company effectively killing all AI startups etc. The same is true of any proprietary information thus quickly killing nvidia, AMD, etc. Medical R&D also dies outside of governments and non profits. It’s shocking just how many industries get gutted as there’s far less incentive to make accurate maps when anyone can copy them.

But hey, I respect your stance here.

PS: If you think contracts/DRM/whatever that’s the solution! Now you do have protection for info and thus IP again.

constantcrying 5 days ago | parent [-]

Sounds fun.

Retric 4 days ago | parent [-]

As long as you know what you’re arguing for I doubt you’ll get many takers, but hey it’s a free country dream whatever you want to dream. At least it’s healthier than dreaming about gunning people down.