Remix.run Logo
Mistletoe 5 days ago

I’ve gotten heart scans twice to monitor coronary artery calcification and get an Agatson score. I wonder how risky this is? I feel like the last time I did it the technician said that the amount of energy they have to use now is much less due to advances in CT scanning machines.

I guess a heart scan is about like six months of natural background radiation according to this chart.

https://www.radiologyinfo.org/en/info/safety-xray

My father’s side has a history of heart attacks, so I’m trying to avoid that fate and consider the risks worth it.

hylaride 5 days ago | parent | next [-]

To maybe oversimplify it, cancer risk from radiation is all a stats game. The situations where you get a CT scan is either very rare (once or twice in a lifetime and often highly localized) or for a very acute issue (eg a heart attack or car accident) that is almost certainly worth the risks.

Also, ionizing radiation has a varying risks to different tissues. "Soft" tissues that have cells that divide a lot (lungs, colon, etc) are of greater risk than others. I wouldn't bat much of an eye for a CT scan on my knee, but would be more worried about a chest procedure. Again, more worried doesn't mean I wouldn't do it, as the alternative is either a much more expensive MRI, much more fuzzy echo-cardiogram, or wondering if my health is more seriously at risk.

oceanplexian 5 days ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Radiation is poorly understood in healthcare due to the LNT Model https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Linear_no-threshold_model.

The science is based on assumptions and extrapolation, they drew a linear plot line between rates of cancers at different levels of radiation, and then extended it down and to the left. But there is no actual experimental data showing a relationship between low dose radiation and cancer (Ironically there IS evidence that rates of overall cancers are lower in high altitude cities like Denver with more background radiation).

AStonesThrow 5 days ago | parent | prev [-]

I’ve remodulated my phaser arrays and randomized the stochastic spectral frequencies ten times, but those Borg keep adapting!!1