Remix.run Logo
voidspark a day ago

AlphaGo Zero didn't just pattern match. It invented moves that it had never been shown before. That is generalization, even if it's domain specific. Humans don't apply Go skills to cooking either.

Calling it machine learning and not AI is just semantics.

For self updating I said it's an engineering choice. You keep moving the goal posts.

Jensson a day ago | parent [-]

> That is generalization, even if it's domain specific

But that is the point, it is a domain specific AI, not a general AI. You can't train a general AI that way.

> For self updating I said it's an engineering choice. You keep moving the goal posts.

No, it is not an engineering choice, it is an unsolved problem to make a general AI that self updates productively. Doing that for a specific well defined problem with well defined goals is easy, but not general problem solving.

voidspark a day ago | parent [-]

You are shifting the goal posts from AI to AGI. That's outside of the scope of the argument.

For self updating - yes it is an engineering choice. It's already engineered in some narrow cases such as AutoML