Remix clone Hacker News

> That's quite interesting, because most of Chinese can only understand what's being colonized, but never understand what's colonizing and genocide.

You are saying that Chinese people don't even realize their colonialism and their genocides. Unless you're sarcastic, it is not the flex you think it is. Also LOL at you using "white" as a slur.

▲

suraci 12 hours ago | parent [-]

You see, that's what I aim to express, but you can not understand

You can only understand such thing with certain history context/knowledge, without it, it's very likely you can not understand what I'm talking about, vice versa, so do I

The difference is I know your history, you don't know mine

like the statement above:

> Everybody already moved to red book and are starting to recognize that the US is just an aging colonialist with nothing to offer the future

it's not true, most Chinese in Xiaohongshu are not recognize the US as 'colonialist', like I said, many of us don't even know what 'colonialist' even mean

They just recognize the US as an aging 'imperialist'(mostly refer to refers to inflation and healthcare), that's what most Chinese can understand

And, 'white' is not a slur, it's history

▲

mrighele 12 hours ago | parent [-]

> You see, that's what I aim to express, but you can not understand

> You can only understand such thing with certain history context/knowledge, without it, it's very likely you can not understand what I'm talking about, vice versa, so do I

Yes I fear so, because know I am even less sure to have understood what you meant; I think we are talking about different things.

>> Everybody already moved to red book and are starting to recognize that the US is just an aging colonialist with nothing to offer the future

> it's not true, most Chinese in Xiaohongshu are not recognize the US as 'colonialist', like I said, many of us don't even know what 'colonialist' even mean

I don't think OP is talking about Chinese people in Xhiaohongshu, but at American people that left Tiktok for it, so it is not about if Chinese people know what colonialism is, but if American people know about (their idea of ) Chinese colonialism.

	▲	suraci 2 hours ago \| parent [-]
		> I don't think OP is talking about Chinese people in Xhiaohongshu, but at American people that left Tiktok for it You are right, I was wrong, skimming reading And this is yet another example to explain how I was haunted by my historical view and you're haunted by yours Let's say, The first time mordern Chinese people learnt about genecide, is from Gaza, before this, fews knew what's it meaning > I think we are talking about different things For example, when American talk about bad of China, it's always about what the US (or 'white') did or experienced, colonization, genocide, force labor, biological weapons, it's in your history and when Chinese people think about bad of the US, it's mostly about imperialism and drugs, because we suffered these, we can not think of the genocide of Native Americans, because it's not in our history so called genocide and colonialism in China, only exists in western narrative, the narrative even only works in Western countries for white people, very few of people in EastAsia/MidEast/African/SouthAmerica would buy this Even in US, some people start to question the narrative after they realize what's the real genocide like in Gaza