Remix.run Logo
ramraj07 5 hours ago

Absolutely, and if you recall, even YC tried to get in on this idea.

Except they did the same mistake anyone who comes up with this disruption plan commits (including Google with Calico, or Zuck with CZI) - they recruit existing academics to do the disruption. Unfortunately this just fails miserably because they’re culturally corrupted to think of standard dogmas (like there can never be a single cure for cancer). I remember a time when other such dogmas existed (remember how it was considered impossible to de-differentiate somatic cells?).

The other mistake tech bros make in biology is they think they can make any cool idea work if they are smart enough. Because this is actually true in tech. But biology is restricted by laws of nature. If a drug doesn’t work, it can’t be made to work. There’s no room for wishful thinking.

Third mistake I see often is individual bias towards fields that they come from. Someone who has an RNA background will only try to use RNA to solve everything, likewise with antibodies, or imaging, etc. The current research funding system incentivizes such thinking and it becomes entrenched in anyone already in this field. There’s never a thought of “which is the exact technology and approach I should use to solve this problem independent of what I’m an expert at?” So a lot of projects are doomed from the start.

As long as you’re cognizant of these three facts, I think it’s very possible to disrupt this field.

nradov an hour ago | parent [-]

Is there any plausible biological reason to think that there could ever be a single cure for cancer?

ckemere an hour ago | parent [-]

Perhaps immune-based therapies like CAR-T are based on the premise that there are many cancerous cells in your body all the time, but your immune system deals with them, and it’s only when it fails to do so that you end up in the pathological state. So the “single cure” is the normally-functioning immune system?

nradov 31 minutes ago | parent [-]

That might be part of it. And yet sometimes people with normally-functioning immune systems also get cancer. So while that might be an effective treatment for some patients it's not going to be a universal cure.