▲ | uzerfcwn 20 hours ago | |
Exceptions are difficult to discuss because different languages implement exceptions differently, each with their own downsides. That said, I don't think anyone has an issue with bubbling. Even sum type proponents love Rust's ? shorthand, because it makes it easier to propagate Results up the stack. The big issue with exceptions in C#, Python and JS is that they're not included in function signatures, which means you have to look up the list of possible exceptions from documentation or source code. This could be amended with checked exceptions like Java, but it allegedly doesn't mesh well with the type system (I haven't personally written Java to confirm this). And then there's the C++ crowd that slaps noexcept on everything for possible performance gains. Personally, I like the way Koka does exceptions with algebraic effects and type inference. It makes exceptions explicit in function signatures but I don't have to rewrite all the return types (like in Rust) because type inference takes care of all that. It also meshes beautifully with the type system, and the same effect system also generalizes to async, generators, forking and other stuff. Alas, Koka is but a research language, so I still write C# for a living. |