Remix.run Logo
bbqfog 10 hours ago

No the idea would be that the search would lose its ability to be a monopoly because Chrome + Search + Maps + Android... would stop artificially propping it up in the market. There would be many search engines and the ability for one to drastically impact other industries with UI changes would go away.

Suppafly 9 hours ago | parent | next [-]

>There would be many search engines and the ability for one to drastically impact other industries with UI changes would go away.

Honestly that's just wishful thinking. Generally these monopolies, regardless of 'artificial propping up' tend to be fairly natural monopolies and these sorts of changes just make it harder on people to get the experience they had before and prefer.

bbqfog 9 hours ago | parent [-]

Not true, look at what happened to Internet Explorer after MS was forced to allow people to uninstall it.

freehorse 5 hours ago | parent | next [-]

The same happens in android, you get a prompt to select your browser in a new phone (not sure if that is eu or not), similar in ios.

Suppafly 9 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

It's not clear to me what point you're making. What happened to IE specifically when MS was forced to allow people to uninstall it?

mattlondon 9 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

But there already are many search engines?

I recently got a couple of new windows laptops and Edge defaulted to Bing, but after changing away from Bing it is relentlessly trying to make me set Bing as the default search engine every few days.

Note that I am using Edge here, not Chrome. Last time I installed Chrome I think it forced me to pick a default search engine, and didn't endlessly harass me to pick Google as its default (I use duck duck go)

I don't see how they could break up Google without forcing MS and Apple to also be broken up too since they're doing the same things with forcing Edge/Bing and Safari on everyone.

snarbles 9 hours ago | parent | next [-]

Edge, Bing, and Safari do not have majority market share. It would still please me to see these companies broken up. They have their own obnoxious and/or harmful practices that are the result or of attempts to be monopolistic.

mattlondon 9 hours ago | parent [-]

I would be surprised to learn that MS does not have majority market share in desktop OSes. Windows still seems to be the default choice - Mac OS and Chrome must be tiny in comparison?

Edit: Windows is 73%, closest is Mac OS at 15% (which was way higher than I expected) https://gs.statcounter.com/os-market-share/desktop/worldwide...

bbqfog 9 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

MS has all the same issues as Google, this is why they can release inferior product and have it survive in the market. I also use DuckDuckGo as would many other people if you severed Google Search's monopolistic lifelines.