Suno is by far the best generated AI music I've heard. That said, it is hot garbage.

I've listened to both songs on my Bose QC ultra headphones, which are far from perfect headphones. But even on them, the female voice has unbearable resonances in the higher frequencies. The male voice sounds mostly ok, but has also something that sounds like compression artifacts (like mp3 compression, not loudness compression). All instruments in these songs have these problems. They sound somewhat like the real thing, but really badly recorded. Also, the mixing isn't any good.

It is still very impressive that AI can generate that. But if I would record my band and someone would create such a mix out of it, I would fire them immediately. Heck, I would be furious that they fucked up so bad and would try to get my money back.

So the two links you provided just confirm what I said.

I use Suno like a producer in a music studio hires musicians to bring ideas to life. I wish more features in Suno would empower music producers. I sample pieces, re-mix doodles, get ideas to continue my tracks... I can see the future, and as an amateur, it's just liberating and a lot of fun.

Really interesting, haven't listened to their output with high quality speakers or anything like that. Do poorly made human recordings have this problem or is this currently a signal of AI generation?