Remix.run Logo
Groxx 4 days ago

Hmmm. Some stuff to like, but I do feel like this should have a big, noticeable cautionary note that it does not wait if you end early (e.g. via Err). Any pending actions continue running and draining in background goroutines, and are potentially VERY delayed if internal/core.Delay is ever exposed or your funcs sleep.

I've seen that kind of pattern lead to TONS of surprise race conditions in user-code, because everyone always thinks that "it returned" means "it's done". Which is reasonable, nothing else is measurable on the caller side - changing that won't be noticeable by callers and may violate their expectations and cause crashes.

destel 4 days ago | parent [-]

Thank you for the feedback. I agree with your point.

The current solution is to make pipeline stages context-aware (which is often happens automatically) and cancel the context before returning. This is the responsibility of the user and can lead to problems you described.

I haven't yet found a better solution to this. On the other hand, exact same thing happens if your function spawns a goroutine and returns. That goroutine would run until done, unless it's context aware.

Regarding the "Delay" and "infiniteBuffer" functions - these are part of the work on adding support for feedback loops to Rill. I haven't yet found a reliable and user friendly way to do it, so this work is on hold for now.