You could have made a sensible argument about how security policies in Israel move in a wrong direction, even if it isn't at all on topic. But you stumbled here too.

It’s a reply to this part of OP:

> Ask IBM what becomes of databases full of people's names associated with their movements.

None of this matters. If a state wants to commit a genocide, they will. Collection of IDs being there or not is a minuscule bump in the road there.