Remix clone Hacker News

That's not going to happen.

Remember when the EU wanted to build it's own internet browser? Or it's own search engine? Or it's own sovereign cloud?

None of these initiatives panned out. This is just political posturing when they have literally zero plans on how to achieve that.

▲

palotasb 7 hours ago | parent | next [-]

But https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Galileo_(satellite_navigation) panned out and that's a closer analogue.

▲

rdm_blackhole 6 hours ago | parent [-]

It took roughly 20 years for the EU to deploy 30 satellites.

How long do you think it's going to take to deploy 300 or so of them when the Ariane 6 had only one launch (with a partial failure) in the last 14 years?

If you want to build a constellation, you need the means to send payloads in space at a relatively low cost. The EU can't do that so it will be an expensive and slow endeavor and by the time those 300 satellites are up there, Space X will have deployed 10s of thousands of them.

You can say, that the EU does not want to compete with Space X or that their goals are not the same but either way, it's just too little too late IMHO.

	▲	rplnt 2 hours ago \| parent [-]
		I agree with your overall point, but that's a super deceptive metric to use. First Ariane 6 was scheduled for 2020 and only the first one ever launched.

▲

verzali 7 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

Or when they built their own GPS system and it ended up being far more accurate than any other system in use? Or when they built their own Earth observation system and it was also better than anyone elses? Or when they built their own weather monitoring constellation and forecast model and it ended up superior to all others? Or when they built the world's most powerful particle collider and discovered the Higgs boson? The world's largest passenger aircraft? The first mRNA Covid-19 vaccine? The weight loss drugs keeping American celebrities thin?

▲

Salmonfisher11 4 hours ago | parent | next [-]

> Or when they built their own GPS system and it ended up being far more accurate than any other system in use?

It actually is. But yes - that project was a shitshow for a long time.

Galileo HAS now offers 30cm accuracy with less than 100s convergence time not needing additional correction servers/stations.

Also spoofing resistant thanks to cryptographic signing (Galileo Open Service Navigation Message Authentication).

Both free for use. Forever. Classic GPS doesn't offer this.

	▲	spacemanspiff01 4 hours ago \| parent [-]
		My impression is that the US system does, but the higher accuracy is still reserved for military use?

▲

rdm_blackhole 6 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

> Or when they built their own GPS system and it ended up being far more accurate than any other system in use?

It took 20 years to deploy 30 satellites. You can call that a success I guess.

> The world's largest passenger aircraft

That is an Airbus project which is not an EU project. Airbus is the result of a merger between multiple companies and was not initiated by the EU.

> The weight loss drugs keeping American celebrities thin?

This drug is manufactured in Denmark by a Danish company. It has nothing to do with the EU.

> The first mRNA Covid-19 vaccine?

You mean the Pfizer vaccine? That's a German company, not an initiative from the EU.

> Or when they built the world's most powerful particle collider and discovered the Higgs boson?

They did build the CERN ... in 1954. Which we can agree was a long time ago. Since then the ability of the EU to deliver big projects such as for example Ariane 6 has gone down rather quickly. Also you ll notice that when the CERN was created, the EU as we know it today did not exist.

> Or when they built their own Earth observation system and it was also better than anyone elses? Or when they built their own weather monitoring constellation and forecast model and it ended up superior to all others?

Ok and so what? Does that invalidate my arguments? A few successes amongst a ton of failures. That does not inspire any confidence.

That is why I am skeptical but I am prepared to eat my own words if the EU has a complete up and running constellation of 300 satellites in orbit by 2035.

The EU has some great companies for sure but these companies did not get there because the EU helped them or because the EU decreed that such companies have to exists.