Remix.run Logo
slowhadoken 15 hours ago

Whenever I hear about Bluesky I think about Jack Dorsey quitting their board and asked people to stay on Twittet/X.

https://amp.theguardian.com/technology/article/2024/may/07/j...

crabmusket 14 hours ago | parent | next [-]

What do you think about it?

What I remember about that whole affair is that I'd really respected Jack for starting Bluesky, allowing it to be independent of Twitter (and Jay deserves a heaping of credit for pushing that!), and then losing that respect when he seemed to totally misunderstand what Bluesky had gone on to achieve.

https://www.techdirt.com/2024/05/13/bluesky-is-building-the-...

Jack was pushing Nostr at the time which... seems ok if you're into that. But his arguments in his interview with Mike Solana really didn't make sense to me.

strogonoff 14 hours ago | parent [-]

Bluesky’s attitude seems logical and their reasoning aligns with my thoughts exactly.

If techdirt’s article is to be believed, Dorsey’s departure has to do with going from an extreme to an extreme—from a traditional social monolith to a pure protocol—whereas Bluesky chose to pursue not only the protocol, but also “the app” as the face of that protocol for the ordinary user, and let’s face it: the ordinary user does not really care about protocols.

My speculation about him suggesting people “stay on Twitter” is that Nostr (which he apparently is invested in now) and Twitter are orthogonal, so there is no conflict there, but Bluesky competes with both.

Not a Bluesky user (the invite-only period has put me off for a while), but if they do not compromise on the protocol part (and there are no shenanigans unfolding, who knows, maybe Dorsey found something) their attitude seems to me to be the most reasonable for a mainstream social platform.

apitman 7 hours ago | parent [-]

What's your issue with invite-only periods? Is there a better way to throttle signups while you scale a system early on?

wesleytodd a few seconds ago | parent | next [-]

But if you use web scale tech you can scale to infinity on day one right? :eye-roll:

irusensei 6 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

The invite-only system established the main Bluesky instance as a big circlejerk.

It worked with Orkut back in the day where the internet was new and untainted by culture wars.

Bluesky is lefty twitter now and I want no business with that platform.

rsynnott 5 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

I mean, honestly, losing Dorsey was probably a big part of its success.