Remix.run Logo
harrall 16 hours ago

I can’t imagine satellites being able to compete with cell towers in bandwidth or capacity.

There are millions of cell towers.

During a major event, cellular companies set up portable cell towers (COWs) and even these are not enough.

And a cell tower that is right next to you still pales in comparison to a single cable in bandwidth.

tssva 15 hours ago | parent | next [-]

They aren't trying to compete with cell towers. SpaceX is partnered with traditional carriers in each country where LTE service will be available and the Starlink service is intended to supplement those services by providing service where existing cell towers can't.

torginus 16 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

Yup. Small cell size is actually a feature for cell phone communications. You have to share bandwidth with everyone in your cell - the smaller the cell, the less crowding.

This is a general starlink issue, which is why I don't understand how is it economically or physically viable in crowded areas, such as cities, where the majority of human population lives.

verzali 6 hours ago | parent [-]

It's not. They don't have the capacity to cover densely populated areas and it will always be cheaper to build out infrastructure on land in those areas than to launch something into space.

torginus 3 hours ago | parent [-]

Honestly try as I might, I have failed to undestand your reply. Who is 'they' in your post?

Aren't you actually agreeing with me in actuality (in that cells are better than satellites for densely populated areas)?