Remix.run Logo
dogleash 21 hours ago

The compiler one read to me like a reminder to not ignore the lessons of compiler design. The premise being that even though you have small scope project compared to a "real" compiler, you will evolve towards analogues of those design ideas. The databases and k8s pieces are more like don't even try a small scope project because you'll want the same features eventually.

ufmace 17 hours ago | parent | next [-]

I suppose I can see how people are taking this piece that way, but I don't see it like that. It is snarky and ranty, which makes it hard to express or perceive nuance. They do explicitly acknowledge that "a single server can go a long way" though.

I think the real point, better expressed, is that if you find yourself building a system with like a third of the features of K8s but composed of hand-rolled scripts and random third-party tools kludged together, maybe you should have just bit the bullet and moved to K8s instead.

You probably shouldn't start your project on it unless you have a dedicated DevOps department maintaining your cluster for you, but don't be afraid to move to it if your needs start getting more complex.

mac-chaffee 15 hours ago | parent [-]

Author here. Yes there were many times while writing this that I wanted to insert nuance, but couldn't without breaking the format too much.

I appreciate the wide range of interpretations! I don't necessarily think you should always move to k8s in those situations. I just want people to not dismiss k8s outright for being overly-complex without thinking too hard about it. "You will evolve towards analogues of those design ideas" is a good way to put it.

That's also how I interpreted the original post about compilers. The reader is stubbornly refusing to acknowledge that compilers have irreducible complexity. They think they can build something simpler, but end up rediscovering the same path that lead to the creation of compilers in the first place.

tptacek 20 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

I had a hard time putting my finger on what was so annoying about the follow-ons to the compiler post, and this nails it for me. Thanks!