Remix.run Logo
▲ ninkendo 2 years ago

It certainly should be the most difficult engineering on the planet, yes… but IME the standards for quality are so low that it’s a pretty easy gig. You’re expected to slap together stuff that barely works and fix things later. That’s now how any other engineering discipline works, or at least not nearly to the same degree. Also it’s hard to observe how hacky software is from the outside, so it’s easy to get away with a terrible mess of code that would nauseate anyone who looked at it. Most of the time management doesn’t even care.

Watching Practical Engineering on YouTube is a pretty illuminating experience for me as it as it shows the extreme care that goes into projects from the outset, how much planning is involved, how much we’ve learned from centuries of experience building things, and how even despite all of this, things can still fail spectacularly. And when it does, there are independent reports done by thorough investigators, who find the real root causes and carry the knowledge forward for future projects. It makes me sad that Software isn’t treated this way. Yes, we get things off the ground fast, but we don’t learn from our mistakes, we don’t conduct thorough investigations into failures, and often people just release things and move on to the next job.

Software may be a more complicated and “difficult” discipline but it sure isn’t treated like it.