Remix.run Logo
deely3 5 days ago

[flagged]

rambojohnson 5 days ago | parent | next [-]

yikes, while your points about Dostoevsky’s views are worth discussing, proclaiming what is or isn't appropriate for this forum as though you're its arbiter seems presumptuous. surely we can engage without the obnoxious gatekeeping of the conversation...

jjtheblunt 5 days ago | parent [-]

it's particularly ironic considering he's discussing Dostoevskiy behaving just as his discussion itself of Dostoevskiy behaves. So silly.

mrtksn 5 days ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Lot's of great people are terrible in some aspect or another. Seeking saints is counterproductive since this is not about celebrating these people's character but their great work.

The whole cancel culture is deeply misguided. It's analogous to expecting wisdom on everything from people who are extremely good at this one thing, but in reverse. It never ends well.

deely3 5 days ago | parent [-]

Sure. I just wish I can recount these wise words to my friends killed by russians army.

mrtksn 5 days ago | parent [-]

I'm sorry to hear that, its terrible what's happening in Ukraine right now but its not a dead writer who is doing it.

hkpack 4 days ago | parent [-]

It absolutely is.

Russia’s ideology is based on the works of such. Look at the quote in the comments above. Dostoevsky approves any sin and logically derives that it will be forgotten. He does not merely condone sin, he rationalizes it, and in doing so, lays bare the grim inevitability of its absolution in the collective psyche.

Living in Kyiv, we were shocked, how a regular person can commit such crimes in a modern day effortlessly, and you can see how - by reading the mind of a russian in the form of a great prose.

Dostoevsky is a window into a sick mind of a crippled nation where death and torture is normalized and the life had no value for at least a millennia.

It is an ideological base of a russian culture, its code, captured by the mastermind who was able to feel it thoroughly.

"It's not a coincidence that one of the last public appearances by Putin before invasion of Ukraine was opening a Dostoyevsky centre in Moscow." [0]

0 - https://www.reddit.com/r/europe/comments/1gxhtcs/comment/lyh...

mrtksn 4 days ago | parent [-]

Let's not fight death people, move on and stick with the good things

havblue 5 days ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Slavophilia is a concept that is hundreds of years old and is essential in understanding the historical and cultural differences between the West and Russia and of course how they interpreted the Enlightenment. This is on the level of importance of Orthodoxy versus Catholicism. It's fine of course to disagree with or dislike historical figures whose views you find abhorrent. Saying that they should not be discussed comes across as McCarthyism.

soperj 5 days ago | parent | prev [-]

Didn't Dostoevsky spend time in Siberia, and basically just miss being executed for offending the Czar?