I don’t think the analogy between rock star developers and LLMs bears out here. Like any other tool, AI abides by the basic reality of garbage in/garbage out. If you don’t make sure the LLM has sufficient context then you get what you get. Same point with vague prompts.

AI tools are producing code on behalf of a developer. If that developer is fine putting their name on code that they don’t understand, applied to a code base they also don’t fully understand then you have a very human problem. The technology just magnifies this.