Remix.run Logo
saltcured 3 hours ago

I find it really disturbing, I think because it is illuminating a much more basic problem. It is there in our political and religious histories. We're living through a similar political time right now. A large number of people seem all to ready to find some pervasive authority and subjugate themselves to it.

The more concrete machine authority figure is also prevalent in scifi literature. Sometimes, I am not even certain if the author is doing this to examine this issue versus just leaning into it as either appealing to themselves or to the perceived audience.

awesome_dude 3 hours ago | parent [-]

Conversely - we tell people who are speaking in public to "Show confidence" - or in job interviews "Hire people who are confident"

We've also pushed back "The more a person knows, the less confident they are" - Dunning Kruger - often used to dismiss over confident people - points out that people are really confident, at first, then that confidence drops away, markedly, but it rebuilds (slowly).

That last rise in confidence is what (I believe) people use as a heuristic on the likely level of knowledge possessed by the speaker (AI or human)

Most engineers know, though, that overconfident people are toxic - the difference between arrogance and genuine confidence in the answer is incredibly difficult to define.