Remix.run Logo
Book Review: On the Calculation of Volume(stephendiehl.com)
22 points by ibobev 3 days ago | 5 comments
jcynix an hour ago | parent | next [-]

Hmm, the review makes me rather curious. While in the movies "Groundhog Day" and "12:01 P.M." the protagonists awake at the same place and time each day.

How do these book explain that the protagonist(s) can relocate to different places? Even if it would give a rationale for that glitch in the loop, it would be strange if you'd check into a hotel and appear to be there the next morning without the check-in?

bradrn 43 minutes ago | parent [-]

Or, for that matter, what if you happened to be in a spot which had been occupied by a person at the time at which it resets?

pkaler 2 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

I'm also currently reading "On the Calculation of Volume". It is fantastic.

Meta-comment about the post. I used to read and write book reviews like this all of the time. Not anymore. ChatGPT and Claude can do a just a good of a job. Now I'm looking for what you think, a unique insight, what did you feel from a book review from a humanoid. LLMs do a fine job summarizing.

PaperTree 2 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

I read Volume I and II when they were released and need to read III and IV as soon as possible. I love the series. You can get lost in it, it feels like writing for your own thoughts.

gostsamo 3 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

Currently reading a web novel called The Years of Apocalypse. Very similar vibe and though it does not have the same literary aspirations as this one, also goes deep in the existential horror of the time loop and the alienation of your old self pinpoint in a constantly moving away past. Time loops are a fractal like that - a very simple idea and one chooses how deep to examine the repeating pattern. Also, seems to follow similar tropes in order to maintain some momentum.