Remix.run Logo
ozim a day ago

*Intuitively it seems like text-first documents (markdown, etc.) should better lend themselves to tools like diff or git, or any other collaboration tool, especially a real-time edit tool.*

Well don’t explain it to me I know that stuff. Go grab 2-3 office workers and try to explain markdown to them. If you’re lucky maybe they won’t leave when you move on to explain Git.

I worked one time with a guy that wanted to convince sales department to write documents in LaTex so then it could be well printed for the customers and also put in Git … well they laughed the guy out of the room - well before he’s even started explaining formats for presentation vs formats for editing.

I see how business people we work with on documents understand I have a cursor here and I type and there is my avatar/photo on top that I am active - I see how they wouldn’t understand Git diff at all and would just move on presented with Git diff not even wanting to collaborate.

tracker1 a day ago | parent [-]

Agreed... The level of integration across MS products in business is hard to entirely quantify.

NextCloud/OwnCloud and other options can deliver some of it, but all of it is harder... Just email/calendar/contacts is hard to match... Then file collaboration and syncing... And all the corner cases in the various office formats.

Even the non mainline office app, Visio does a lot of things competing apps just don't.

I tend to prefer open source apps for myself, and for code projects, I'll focus on markdown for docs etc... but definitely understand why a corp would just pay the monthly Microsoft tax for all employees.

With the improved web versions, Linux on the desktop becomes an option even then.