Remix.run Logo
msm_ a day ago

>EDR/AV is basically unnecessary, when you only mount things either writable or executable

Sounds good, except:

* scripting languages exist. The situation is even worse on Linux than on Windows (because of the sysadmin focus). You need at least /bin/sh installed and runnable on any POSIX system. In practice bash, python, perl and many more are also always available.

* exploits exist. Just opening a pdf file may execute arbitrary code on a machine. There is no way to avoid that by just configuring your system. And it will happen sooner or later, especially if nation states are involved.

The idea that your systems are somehow unhackable because you... mount everything W^X is... not based in reality. Of course it's a great idea, but in practice you need defense in depth, and you need to have a way to Detect and Respond to inevitable Endpoint breaches. I don't love EDR/AVs, but they mitigate real attacks happening in the real world.